{ "allClaimsLinked": true, "allSelectedSourcesReferenced": true, "baselineRelease": "v100.0.45-ai-psyops-citation-integrity-wip", "categoryClaimEdgeCount": 501, "categoryCount": 12, "claimCount": 501, "claimSourceEdgeCount": 3656, "edgeCount": 4157, "edges": [ { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0001" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0002" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0003" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0004" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0005" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0006" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0007" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0008" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0009" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0010" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0011" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0012" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0013" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0014" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0015" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0016" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0017" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0018" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0019" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0020" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0021" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0022" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0023" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0024" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0025" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0026" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0027" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0028" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0029" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0030" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0031" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0032" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0033" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0034" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0035" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0036" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0037" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0038" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0039" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0040" }, { "from": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-01-0041" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0042" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0043" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0044" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0045" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0046" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0047" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0048" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0049" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0050" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0051" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0052" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0053" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0054" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0055" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0056" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0057" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0058" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0059" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0060" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0061" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0062" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0063" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0064" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0065" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0066" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0067" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0068" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0069" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0070" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0071" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0072" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0073" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0074" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0075" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0076" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0077" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0078" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0079" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0080" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0081" }, { "from": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-02-0082" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0083" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0084" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0085" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0086" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0087" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0088" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0089" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0090" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0091" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0092" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0093" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0094" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0095" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0096" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0097" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0098" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0099" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0100" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0101" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0102" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0103" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0104" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0105" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0106" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0107" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0108" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0109" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0110" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0111" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0112" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0113" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0114" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0115" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0116" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0117" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0118" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0119" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0120" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0121" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0122" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0123" }, { "from": "category:personalized-influence", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-03-0124" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0125" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0126" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0127" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0128" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0129" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0130" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0131" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0132" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0133" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0134" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0135" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0136" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0137" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0138" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0139" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0140" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0141" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0142" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0143" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0144" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0145" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0146" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0147" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0148" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0149" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0150" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0151" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0152" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0153" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0154" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0155" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0156" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0157" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0158" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0159" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0160" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0161" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0162" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0163" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0164" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0165" }, { "from": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-04-0166" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0167" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0168" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0169" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0170" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0171" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0172" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0173" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0174" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0175" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0176" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0177" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0178" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0179" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0180" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0181" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0182" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0183" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0184" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0185" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0186" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0187" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0188" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0189" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0190" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0191" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0192" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0193" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0194" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0195" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0196" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0197" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0198" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0199" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0200" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0201" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0202" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0203" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0204" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0205" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0206" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0207" }, { "from": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-05-0208" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0209" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0210" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0211" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0212" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0213" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0214" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0215" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0216" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0217" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0218" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0219" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0220" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0221" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0222" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0223" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0224" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0225" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0226" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0227" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0228" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0229" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0230" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0231" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0232" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0233" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0234" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0235" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0236" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0237" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0238" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0239" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0240" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0241" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0242" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0243" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0244" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0245" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0246" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0247" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0248" }, { "from": "category:disinformation-swarms", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-06-0249" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0250" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0251" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0252" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0253" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0254" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0255" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0256" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0257" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0258" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0259" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0260" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0261" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0262" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0263" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0264" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0265" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0266" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0267" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0268" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0269" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0270" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0271" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0272" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0273" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0274" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0275" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0276" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0277" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0278" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0279" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0280" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0281" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0282" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0283" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0284" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0285" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0286" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0287" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0288" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0289" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0290" }, { "from": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-07-0291" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0292" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0293" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0294" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0295" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0296" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0297" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0298" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0299" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0300" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0301" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0302" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0303" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0304" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0305" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0306" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0307" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0308" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0309" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0310" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0311" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0312" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0313" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0314" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0315" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0316" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0317" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0318" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0319" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0320" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0321" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0322" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0323" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0324" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0325" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0326" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0327" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0328" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0329" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0330" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0331" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0332" }, { "from": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-08-0333" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0334" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0335" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0336" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0337" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0338" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0339" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0340" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0341" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0342" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0343" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0344" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0345" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0346" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0347" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0348" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0349" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0350" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0351" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0352" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0353" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0354" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0355" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0356" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0357" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0358" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0359" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0360" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0361" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0362" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0363" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0364" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0365" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0366" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0367" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0368" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0369" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0370" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0371" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0372" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0373" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0374" }, { "from": "category:conversational-entrapment", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-09-0375" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0376" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0377" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0378" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0379" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0380" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0381" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0382" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0383" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0384" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0385" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0386" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0387" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0388" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0389" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0390" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0391" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0392" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0393" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0394" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0395" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0396" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0397" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0398" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0399" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0400" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0401" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0402" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0403" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0404" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0405" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0406" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0407" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0408" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0409" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0410" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0411" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0412" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0413" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0414" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0415" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0416" }, { "from": "category:deepfake-psyops", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-10-0417" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0418" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0419" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0420" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0421" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0422" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0423" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0424" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0425" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0426" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0427" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0428" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0429" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0430" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0431" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0432" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0433" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0434" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0435" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0436" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0437" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0438" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0439" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0440" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0441" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0442" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0443" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0444" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0445" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0446" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0447" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0448" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0449" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0450" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0451" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0452" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0453" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0454" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0455" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0456" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0457" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0458" }, { "from": "category:predictive-population-management", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-11-0459" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0460" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0461" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0462" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0463" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0464" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0465" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0466" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0467" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0468" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0469" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0470" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0471" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0472" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0473" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0474" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0475" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0476" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0477" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0478" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0479" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0480" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0481" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0482" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0483" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0484" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0485" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0486" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0487" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0488" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0489" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0490" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0491" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0492" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0493" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0494" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0495" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0496" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0497" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0498" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0499" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0500" }, { "from": "category:psychological-authority", "relation": "contains-claim", "to": "claim:AIP-12-0501" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0020", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0021", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0061", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0061", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0062", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0102", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0103", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s32" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:personalized-influence-s46" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0144", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0145", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0145", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0186", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0187", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0228", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0228", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0229", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0269", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0270", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0311", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0312", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0312", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0353", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0353", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0354", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0354", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0395", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0396", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0437", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0437", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0437", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0438", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0438", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s1" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s3" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s12" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s21" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s45" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s24" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s25" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:predictive-population-management-s22" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0479", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0479", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0480", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0480", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s2" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s4" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s6" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s8" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s20" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s5" }, { "from": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "relation": "supported-or-qualified-by", "to": "source:psychological-authority-s15" } ], "generatedAtUtc": "2026-07-27T22:45:00Z", "humanEditorialReviewPerformed": false, "nodes": { "categories": [ { "id": "category:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "kind": "category", "number": 1, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/ai-assisted-traditional-psyops/", "slug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "title": "AI-Assisted Traditional Psychological Operations" }, { "id": "category:ai-generated-propaganda", "kind": "category", "number": 2, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/ai-generated-propaganda/", "slug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "title": "AI-Generated Propaganda" }, { "id": "category:personalized-influence", "kind": "category", "number": 3, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/personalized-influence/", "slug": "personalized-influence", "title": "AI-Driven Personalized Influence Operations" }, { "id": "category:autonomous-influence-agents", "kind": "category", "number": 4, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/autonomous-influence-agents/", "slug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "title": "Autonomous AI Influence Agents" }, { "id": "category:synthetic-persona-operations", "kind": "category", "number": 5, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/synthetic-persona-operations/", "slug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "title": "Synthetic Persona Operations" }, { "id": "category:disinformation-swarms", "kind": "category", "number": 6, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/disinformation-swarms/", "slug": "disinformation-swarms", "title": "AI-Driven Disinformation Swarms" }, { "id": "category:algorithmic-perception-control", "kind": "category", "number": 7, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/algorithmic-perception-control/", "slug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "title": "Algorithmic Perception Control" }, { "id": "category:emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "kind": "category", "number": 8, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/emotional-behavioral-manipulation/", "slug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "title": "AI-Enabled Emotional and Behavioral Manipulation" }, { "id": "category:conversational-entrapment", "kind": "category", "number": 9, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/conversational-entrapment/", "slug": "conversational-entrapment", "title": "AI-Assisted Conversational Entrapment and Recruitment" }, { "id": "category:deepfake-psyops", "kind": "category", "number": 10, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/deepfake-psyops/", "slug": "deepfake-psyops", "title": "AI-Enabled Deepfake Psychological Operations" }, { "id": "category:predictive-population-management", "kind": "category", "number": 11, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/predictive-population-management/", "slug": "predictive-population-management", "title": "AI-Based Predictive Population Management" }, { "id": "category:psychological-authority", "kind": "category", "number": 12, "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/psychological-authority/", "slug": "psychological-authority", "title": "AI as an Independent Psychological Authority" } ], "claims": [ { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0001", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0001", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0001", "statement": "Human planners retain strategic control while AI assists with research, translation, production, audience analysis, simulation, or measurement inside an established influence workflow." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0002", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0002", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0002", "statement": "Human-led psychological or strategic-influence activity in which AI supports bounded stages such as information synthesis, translation, content drafting, simulation, distribution support, or evaluation." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0003", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0003", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0003", "statement": "Fully autonomous systems choosing political objectives without human direction; transparent public communication is not automatically a psychological operation merely because AI assisted its production." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0004", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0004", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0004", "statement": "AI can reduce production friction and accelerate feedback loops while human operators retain strategic intent and accountability." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0005", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0005", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0005", "statement": "The immediate change is organizational: tasks that once required large multilingual teams can be performed faster and at lower cost." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0006", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0006", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0006", "statement": "The same systems can support lawful public communication or deceptive operations, so intent, attribution, consent, and oversight remain decisive." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0007", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0007", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0007", "statement": "Faster synthesis of large information collections." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0008", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0008", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0008", "statement": "Low-cost translation and localization, with continuing cultural-error risk." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0009", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0009", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0009", "statement": "Rapid generation of multiple media variants." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0010", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0010", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0010", "statement": "Simulation and message comparison before release, although synthetic audiences are not proof of real-world effects." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0011", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0011", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0011", "statement": "Near-real-time monitoring that can encourage overreaction to weak engagement signals." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0012", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0012", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0012", "statement": "Confirmed real-world use: Reports from platforms and public authorities describe AI used for drafting, translation, persona support, research, and technical assistance in covert influence activity." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0013", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0013", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0013", "statement": "Demonstrated technical capability: Controlled studies show that conversational models can be persuasive under bounded conditions, especially when given target information." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0014", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0014", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0014", "statement": "Effect remains uncertain: High output, reach, or engagement does not establish durable belief or behavior change." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0015", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0015", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0015", "statement": "Machine-assisted audience and narrative analysis." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0016", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0016", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0016", "statement": "Human-reviewed generation and localization." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0017", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0017", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0017", "statement": "Synthetic pretesting and scenario comparison." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0018", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0018", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0018", "statement": "Automated scheduling and measurement." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0019", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0019", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0019", "statement": "Human approval and deployment remain the defining control point." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0020", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0020", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0020", "statement": "STOIC / “Zero Zeno” Confirmed AI assistance A commercial influence-for-hire operation used AI to generate articles, comments, and persona material across several countries. Platform threat reporting confirmed AI use and disrupted the activity. The report describes low organic engagement despite high production volume. Whether the campaign changed attitudes or behavior among people who saw it remains unestablished." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0021", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0021", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0021", "statement": "Doppelgänger Confirmed AI assistance A Russian-aligned operation used AI-supported translation, rewriting, and short-form content around cloned or deceptive media properties. Public technical reporting documented the campaign and multilingual dissemination infrastructure. Production scale and cross-language reach were observable. Long-term persuasive effects and the contribution of AI relative to established human tradecraft remain uncertain." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0022", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0022", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0022", "statement": "Hallucinated or culturally inappropriate content can create strategic backfire." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0023", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0023", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0023", "statement": "Automation bias can cause operators to over-trust weak audience models." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0024", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0024", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0024", "statement": "Faster production can overwhelm verification and moderation capacity." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0025", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0025", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0025", "statement": "Attribution becomes harder when operations are outsourced or distributed." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0026", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0026", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0026", "statement": "Current systems do not reliably understand cultural context." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0027", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0027", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0027", "statement": "Synthetic audience simulations can amplify the assumptions placed into them." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0028", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0028", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0028", "statement": "Engagement metrics are poor proxies for belief or behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0029", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0029", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0029", "statement": "Human strategic direction and infrastructure remain central in documented cases." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0030", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0030", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0030", "statement": "Indicator: Synchronized multilingual narrative changes across many accounts or sites. Caveat: Coordination can also reflect legitimate campaigns or shared news events." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0031", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0031", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0031", "statement": "Indicator: Repeated artifacts showing model instructions or safety refusals in published content. Caveat: This is strong evidence of automation error but not proof of a specific sponsor." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0032", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0032", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0032", "statement": "Indicator: Rapid content pivots immediately following audience reactions. Caveat: Professional communications teams also adapt quickly." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0033", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0033", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0033", "statement": "Maintain human legal and editorial approval for high-impact communications." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0034", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0034", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0034", "statement": "Use independent source verification rather than model-generated citations." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0035", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0035", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0035", "statement": "Audit audience models for cultural and sampling bias." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0036", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0036", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0036", "statement": "Separate reach, engagement, attitude, and behavior metrics." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0037", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0037", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0037", "statement": "Invest in network-level detection and transparent takedown reporting." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0038", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0038", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0038", "statement": "How much AI changes outcomes rather than production volume." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0039", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0039", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0039", "statement": "When synthetic audience simulations generalize to real populations." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0040", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0040", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0040", "statement": "How outsourced influence-for-hire markets change responsibility and attribution." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-01-0041", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-01-0041", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-assisted-traditional-psyops#claim-AIP-01-0041", "statement": "Which oversight structures prevent automation bias in state and commercial settings." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0042", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0042", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0042", "statement": "Generative systems create or substantially transform propaganda text, images, audio, video, memes, documents, or synthetic news formats for an organized objective." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0043", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0043", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0043", "statement": "Organized persuasive communication in which AI generates or substantially transforms content intended to advance a political, military, ideological, commercial, or organizational objective." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0044", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0044", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0044", "statement": "All synthetic media, satire, ordinary advertising, or accidental misinformation; propaganda requires organized purpose and context." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0045", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0045", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0045", "statement": "Generative AI sharply lowers the cost of producing plausible, localized propaganda and contributes to uncertainty about authentic evidence." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0046", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0046", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0046", "statement": "AI changes the economics of propaganda by making variation, translation, and rapid crisis response inexpensive." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0047", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0047", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0047", "statement": "The broader harm includes the liar’s dividend: authentic evidence can be dismissed as synthetic once audiences know convincing fakes are possible." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0048", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0048", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0048", "statement": "Industrial-scale text and media production." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0049", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0049", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0049", "statement": "Rapid localization across languages and communities." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0050", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0050", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0050", "statement": "Fast response during breaking-news information gaps." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0051", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0051", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0051", "statement": "High-volume variation that defeats simple duplicate matching." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0052", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0052", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0052", "statement": "Creation of synthetic “news” formats and fabricated documentary artifacts." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0053", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0053", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0053", "statement": "Confirmed real-world use: Threat reporting and investigations document AI-generated or AI-rewritten propaganda in state-aligned operations and election-related incidents." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0054", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0054", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0054", "statement": "Demonstrated persuasion: Controlled experiments cited by the report found AI-generated propaganda could be about as persuasive as human-written material in the tested settings." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0055", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0055", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0055", "statement": "Population effects uncertain: Distribution and engagement do not establish durable political or behavioral change." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0056", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0056", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0056", "statement": "Automated article and social-post generation." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0057", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0057", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0057", "statement": "Synthetic image, audio, and video production." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0058", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0058", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0058", "statement": "Localization and rhetorical reframing." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0059", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0059", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0059", "statement": "Artificial consensus through many variants." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0060", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0060", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0060", "statement": "Credibility laundering through familiar media formats." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0061", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0061", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0061", "statement": "CopyCop / DC Weekly Confirmed AI assistance A network used generative systems to rewrite and expand news-like content in support of strategic narratives. Researchers identified a transition to AI-assisted rewriting and model artifacts in published material. Output volume and topic breadth increased; experimental work found retained short-term persuasiveness. The degree of durable attitude or voting change remains unknown." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0062", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0062", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0062", "statement": "New Hampshire primary robocall Confirmed synthetic audio Voters received robocalls using a cloned presidential voice that told them not to participate in the primary. Investigations attributed the call operation and established use of voice cloning. Thousands of calls were placed and enforcement action followed. The number of voters whose behavior changed cannot be reliably isolated." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0063", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0063", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0063", "statement": "Volume can outpace verification and newsroom response." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0064", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0064", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0064", "statement": "Synthetic content can exploit crisis timing and existing prejudice." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0065", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0065", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0065", "statement": "False accusations of deepfakery can shield authentic misconduct." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0066", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0066", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0066", "statement": "Labels and detectors can create false confidence or reduce trust in accurate content." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0067", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0067", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0067", "statement": "High volume often produces little organic engagement." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0068", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0068", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0068", "statement": "AI output can contain factual and cultural errors." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0069", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0069", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0069", "statement": "Quality varies substantially by modality and human oversight." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0070", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0070", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0070", "statement": "Persuasion effects depend on source, prior belief, timing, and context." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0071", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0071", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0071", "statement": "Indicator: Large clusters of stylistically varied content repeating one narrative. Caveat: Shared themes can also arise organically after major events." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0072", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0072", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0072", "statement": "Indicator: Synthetic media without a verifiable source trail. Caveat: Missing provenance does not prove fabrication." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0073", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0073", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0073", "statement": "Indicator: News-like sites with copied layouts, weak ownership records, and coordinated distribution. Caveat: Each signal requires corroboration before attribution." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0074", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0074", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0074", "statement": "Publish authentic media through trusted, signed channels." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0075", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0075", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0075", "statement": "Use narrative-level triage instead of attempting to debunk every variant." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0076", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0076", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0076", "statement": "Preserve evidence and disclose attribution confidence." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0077", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0077", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0077", "statement": "Support provenance while acknowledging metadata stripping and false negatives." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0078", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0078", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0078", "statement": "Teach audiences that AI labels and detection scores are not verdicts." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0079", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0079", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0079", "statement": "Long-term behavioral impact of AI-generated propaganda." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0080", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0080", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0080", "statement": "How disclosure labels affect true and false content differently." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0081", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0081", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0081", "statement": "Robust provenance after reposting, compression, or screenshotting." }, { "categorySlug": "ai-generated-propaganda", "claimId": "AIP-02-0082", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-02-0082", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=ai-generated-propaganda#claim-AIP-02-0082", "statement": "How generative media changes the liar’s dividend across political contexts." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0083", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0083", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0083", "statement": "AI systems tailor messages or interactions to information collected or inferred about a person, then may adapt the communication using ongoing feedback." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0084", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0084", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0084", "statement": "Organized attempts to influence a person using collected or inferred attributes, tailored communication, and adaptive feedback." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0085", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0085", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0085", "statement": "User-directed customization and transparent recommendations that support the user’s stated goal without covert vulnerability exploitation." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0086", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0086", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0086", "statement": "The most established harm is covert data asymmetry and vulnerability exploitation, not reliable “mind control” through personality targeting." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0087", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0087", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0087", "statement": "Even weak profiling can be intrusive, discriminatory, and difficult to contest when it shapes political, financial, or interpersonal treatment." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0088", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0088", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0088", "statement": "Generative systems make individualized communication inexpensive, but the claimed persuasive advantage of psychographic matching is much less certain than marketing narratives suggest." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0089", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0089", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0089", "statement": "Automates individualized message drafting." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0090", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0090", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0090", "statement": "Combines many data sources into inferred profiles." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0091", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0091", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0091", "statement": "Adapts tone and content after each response." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0092", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0092", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0092", "statement": "Tests message variants continuously." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0093", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0093", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0093", "statement": "Can target temporary distress or life events rather than stable traits." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0094", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0094", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0094", "statement": "Confirmed profiling and targeting: Commercial and political systems routinely segment and personalize based on behavioral and demographic data." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0095", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0095", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0095", "statement": "Demonstrated generic AI persuasion: LLM-generated messages can be persuasive in controlled settings." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0096", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0096", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0096", "statement": "Personalization advantage contested: The report cites meta-analytic and experimental evidence that the incremental benefit of personality-based targeting may approach zero after correcting methodological problems." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0097", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0097", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0097", "statement": "Collection of demographic, behavioral, network, and contextual data." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0098", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0098", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0098", "statement": "Inference of interests or temporary vulnerability." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0099", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0099", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0099", "statement": "Message selection or generation." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0100", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0100", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0100", "statement": "Feedback-based optimization." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0101", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0101", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0101", "statement": "Cross-platform identity and data linkage." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0102", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0102", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0102", "statement": "Cambridge Analytica Data use confirmed; persuasive effect unproven Facebook data was harvested and used for political profiling and targeting claims. Large-scale data-protection violations and covert processing were documented. Regulatory and public-trust consequences were substantial. Investigations did not establish that psychographic targeting changed the Brexit or U.S. election result." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0103", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0103", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0103", "statement": "LLM political microtargeting experiment Controlled experiment Researchers compared generic and individually tailored political messages generated by language models. AI-generated messages were persuasive in the study. Tailored messages did not show a statistically reliable advantage over generic AI messages. Longer multi-turn interaction and different populations require further study." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0104", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0104", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0104", "statement": "Covert processing undermines informed choice." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0105", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0105", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0105", "statement": "Weak inferences can produce discriminatory stereotypes." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0106", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0106", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0106", "statement": "Temporary distress can be exploited at high-stakes moments." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0107", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0107", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0107", "statement": "Personalization can fragment the public sphere and make scrutiny difficult." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0108", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0108", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0108", "statement": "Personality inference from digital traces is weaker than commonly claimed." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0109", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0109", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0109", "statement": "Emotion recognition from faces or voices lacks reliable scientific foundation." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0110", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0110", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0110", "statement": "Models may confuse correlation with causation." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0111", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0111", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0111", "statement": "Targets and auditors often cannot see the messages delivered to others." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0112", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0112", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0112", "statement": "Indicator: Messages make unusually specific reference to private or recent life events. Caveat: The detail could come from ordinary account history, a breach, or human knowledge." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0113", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0113", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0113", "statement": "Indicator: A system changes framing or pressure immediately after hesitation. Caveat: Adaptive customer support can behave similarly without manipulative intent." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0114", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0114", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0114", "statement": "Indicator: Users receive materially different political claims without a public archive. Caveat: Variation alone does not establish harmful targeting." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0115", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0115", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0115", "statement": "Data minimization and restrictions on sensitive inference." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0116", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0116", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0116", "statement": "Transparent “why am I seeing this?” explanations." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0117", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0117", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0117", "statement": "Public political-ad libraries with meaningful targeting information." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0118", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0118", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0118", "statement": "Independent audits and researcher access." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0119", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0119", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0119", "statement": "Prohibit or strictly limit emotion inference and exploitation of vulnerable groups." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0120", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0120", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0120", "statement": "Make contextual rather than behavioral advertising the default where feasible." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0121", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0121", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0121", "statement": "Multi-turn adaptive persuasion outside laboratory settings." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0122", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0122", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0122", "statement": "Effects on vulnerable subgroups rather than population averages." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0123", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0123", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0123", "statement": "Auditing personalized messages without collecting more sensitive data." }, { "categorySlug": "personalized-influence", "claimId": "AIP-03-0124", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-03-0124", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=personalized-influence#claim-AIP-03-0124", "statement": "How temporary life events alter susceptibility and risk." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0125", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0125", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0125", "statement": "Goal-directed software agents observe, remember, plan, communicate, use tools, and adapt toward an influence objective with varying degrees of human supervision." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0126", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0126", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0126", "statement": "Software systems that pursue an influence-related goal through repeated communication or online action with limited ongoing direction." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0127", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0127", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0127", "statement": "Simple scheduled bots, human-authored posts distributed automatically, or ordinary customer-service systems with tightly bounded rules." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0128", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0128", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0128", "statement": "Agentic systems combine communication with memory and action, but current long-horizon reliability is much weaker than fluent short-term behavior suggests." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0129", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0129", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0129", "statement": "Agents can sustain many interactions and connect language generation to tools, accounts, and data." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0130", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0130", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0130", "statement": "The risk grows with memory, permissions, coordination, and the ability to revise strategies, but fluent messages should not be mistaken for durable autonomy." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0131", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0131", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0131", "statement": "Persistent memory and persona continuity." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0132", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0132", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0132", "statement": "Planning loops and tool invocation." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0133", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0133", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0133", "statement": "Continuous interaction at machine scale." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0134", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0134", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0134", "statement": "Coordination among specialized agents." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0135", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0135", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0135", "statement": "Feedback-based strategy revision in bounded environments." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0136", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0136", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0136", "statement": "Short-term capabilities established: Models generate persuasive text, use tools, and sustain bounded multi-turn interaction." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0137", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0137", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0137", "statement": "Sandboxed coordination demonstrated: Synthetic social networks and laboratory multi-agent systems show role division and emergent interaction." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0138", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0138", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0138", "statement": "Long-horizon autonomy speculative: Multi-month strategic coherence, infrastructure management, and reliable evasion without human intervention remain unsupported." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0139", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0139", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0139", "statement": "Observation and profile maintenance." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0140", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0140", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0140", "statement": "Working and long-term memory." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0141", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0141", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0141", "statement": "Plan–act–evaluate loops." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0142", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0142", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0142", "statement": "Bounded external tool access." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0143", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0143", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0143", "statement": "Role division among multiple agents." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0144", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0144", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0144", "statement": "Chirper.ai synthetic social network Demonstrated in a sandboxed platform Thousands of LLM-driven accounts interacted in a synthetic social network after initial configuration. Researchers observed large-scale autonomous posting and social-network patterns. The system demonstrated synthetic interaction and emergent toxic behavior. It did not prove reliable deployment or moderation evasion on real social platforms." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0145", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0145", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0145", "statement": "PRC-linked AI debate operations Confirmed AI use; low autonomy Operators used AI to generate and adapt content around U.S. technology and trade debates. Platform threat reporting documented the use of AI services. The activity demonstrated human-directed generation and research assistance. The models did not independently operate accounts or set strategy; real autonomy was low." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0146", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0146", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0146", "statement": "Tool permissions can turn persuasive interaction into real action." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0147", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0147", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0147", "statement": "Persistent memory can accumulate sensitive information or be poisoned." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0148", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0148", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0148", "statement": "Multi-agent coordination can fabricate social proof." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0149", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0149", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0149", "statement": "Long-running agents can drift, hallucinate, or become sycophantic." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0150", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0150", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0150", "statement": "Attention and reasoning degrade across long tasks." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0151", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0151", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0151", "statement": "Memory retrieval can become stale or noisy." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0152", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0152", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0152", "statement": "Models are vulnerable to prompt injection and goal drift." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0153", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0153", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0153", "statement": "Real-world campaigns still require human infrastructure and oversight." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0154", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0154", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0154", "statement": "Indicator: Persistent accounts exhibit abrupt memory or persona discontinuities. Caveat: Humans and legitimate bots can also change behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0155", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0155", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0155", "statement": "Indicator: Accounts divide roles in a highly regular interaction pattern. Caveat: Formal organizations may coordinate lawfully." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0156", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0156", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0156", "statement": "Indicator: Tool actions occur at machine speed or outside plausible human schedules. Caveat: Scheduled accessibility and support tools can look similar." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0157", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0157", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0157", "statement": "Require clear AI identity disclosure." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0158", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0158", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0158", "statement": "Use least-privilege, short-lived tool permissions." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0159", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0159", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0159", "statement": "Limit execution steps and require reauthorization." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0160", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0160", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0160", "statement": "Keep immutable audit records without storing private content unnecessarily." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0161", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0161", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0161", "statement": "Provide emergency suspension and state rollback." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0162", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0162", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0162", "statement": "Evaluate agents in sandboxes rather than on unwitting populations." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0163", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0163", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0163", "statement": "Reliable measurement of long-horizon strategic coherence." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0164", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0164", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0164", "statement": "Detection of agents that deliberately vary behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0165", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0165", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0165", "statement": "Governance responsibility across model provider, developer, deployer, and platform." }, { "categorySlug": "autonomous-influence-agents", "claimId": "AIP-04-0166", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-04-0166", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=autonomous-influence-agents#claim-AIP-04-0166", "statement": "Safe evaluation of persuasion without exposing real users." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0167", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0167", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0167", "statement": "Fabricated identities use generated images, biographies, voices, and language to appear human, gain trust, infiltrate communities, or manufacture consensus." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0168", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0168", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0168", "statement": "Fabricated or substantially fictional identities presented as real people, experts, organizations, witnesses, activists, journalists, or community members for a deceptive objective." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0169", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0169", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0169", "statement": "Transparent avatars, ordinary pseudonyms used by real people, satire, disclosed role-play, and legitimate accessibility bots." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0170", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0170", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0170", "statement": "AI lowers the cost of maintaining convincing fictional identities while automated detection can wrongly accuse legitimate anonymous or non-native users." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0171", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0171", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0171", "statement": "People normally default to assuming social partners are genuine, and online environments provide fewer cues for checking identity." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0172", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0172", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0172", "statement": "Synthetic identity networks can borrow credibility from one another, while overbroad identity verification can endanger whistleblowers and dissidents." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0173", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0173", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0173", "statement": "Creates unique face and voice assets." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0174", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0174", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0174", "statement": "Maintains biographies and linguistic style." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0175", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0175", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0175", "statement": "Localizes personas across cultures and languages." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0176", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0176", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0176", "statement": "Generates routine background activity." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0177", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0177", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0177", "statement": "Allows many identities to interact and reinforce one another." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0178", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0178", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0178", "statement": "Confirmed identity fabrication: Investigations document AI-generated profile images, synthetic presenters, and deepfake-assisted remote impersonation." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0179", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0179", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0179", "statement": "Scaled persona generation demonstrated: Research systems can generate diverse persona populations, although realism and long-term consistency vary." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0180", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0180", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0180", "statement": "Long-term credibility uneven: Physical-world records, live interaction, and coherent history remain difficult to fabricate consistently." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0181", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0181", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0181", "statement": "Generated identity assets." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0182", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0182", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0182", "statement": "Fabricated biography and credentials." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0183", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0183", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0183", "statement": "Language and cultural mirroring." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0184", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0184", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0184", "statement": "Networked credibility and artificial consensus." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0185", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0185", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0185", "statement": "Cross-platform reuse or identity theft." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0186", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0186", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0186", "statement": "Oliver Taylor Synthetic identity confirmed; text assistance alleged A nonexistent “student journalist” published accusations through recognized outlets using a generated profile image. Investigators found the person did not exist and the image showed GAN-generation indicators. The persona obtained publication and reputational reach. Whether article text was AI-generated was not conclusively established." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0187", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0187", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0187", "statement": "DPRK remote-worker infiltration Confirmed AI-assisted identity deception Operatives used false or stolen identities, AI-generated images, and remote-interview deception to obtain employment. Public corporate and government reporting documented infiltrations and synthetic identity assets. Some operatives reached enterprise onboarding and network access. Public reporting does not reveal every tool or the full scale of successful placements." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0188", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0188", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0188", "statement": "Fabricated experts or community members can gain trust and launder claims." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0189", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0189", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0189", "statement": "Networks can manufacture popularity and agreement." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0190", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0190", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0190", "statement": "Identity assets support fraud and enterprise access." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0191", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0191", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0191", "statement": "AI detectors can discriminate against non-native and neurodivergent users." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0192", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0192", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0192", "statement": "Long-term biographical consistency remains fragile." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0193", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0193", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0193", "statement": "Live video and offline verification can expose anomalies." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0194", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0194", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0194", "statement": "Authentic humans may share the same linguistic or behavioral signals as models." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0195", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0195", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0195", "statement": "Mandatory real-name systems can create serious civil-liberties harms." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0196", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0196", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0196", "statement": "Indicator: Conflicting biography or credential claims across time and platforms. Caveat: People make mistakes, change roles, or use satire." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0197", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0197", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0197", "statement": "Indicator: Dense new-account clusters that mutually reinforce credibility. Caveat: Legitimate new communities can grow quickly." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0198", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0198", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0198", "statement": "Indicator: Identity imagery lacks a verifiable provenance trail. Caveat: Most authentic images also lack cryptographic provenance." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0199", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0199", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0199", "statement": "Use risk-based, context-specific verification rather than universal real-name mandates." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0200", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0200", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0200", "statement": "Combine content, behavior, network, and infrastructure signals." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0201", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0201", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0201", "statement": "Provide appeals before punitive action." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0202", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0202", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0202", "statement": "Protect legitimate pseudonymity." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0203", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0203", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0203", "statement": "Document attribution confidence and preserve forensic evidence." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0204", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0204", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0204", "statement": "Use out-of-band verification for high-stakes employment or financial access." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0205", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0205", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0205", "statement": "Fair detection with acceptable false-positive rates." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0206", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0206", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0206", "statement": "Long-term synthetic identity maintenance in adversarial environments." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0207", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0207", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0207", "statement": "How communities recover trust after an infiltration." }, { "categorySlug": "synthetic-persona-operations", "claimId": "AIP-05-0208", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-05-0208", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=synthetic-persona-operations#claim-AIP-05-0208", "statement": "Proportional identity assurance that preserves anonymity and dissent." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0209", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0209", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0209", "statement": "Coordinated or emergent collections of accounts, agents, media assets, and sites generate, vary, distribute, and amplify misleading narratives at high speed." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0210", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0210", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0210", "statement": "Networks that coordinate many changing messages, identities, and media properties to amplify narratives, simulate debate, or overwhelm verification." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0211", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0211", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0211", "statement": "Ordinary viral misinformation, genuine decentralized activism, conventional spam, or simple copy-paste botnets without adaptive coordination." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0212", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0212", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0212", "statement": "The strategic effect may be confusion and exhaustion rather than belief in one false claim, making item-by-item fact-checking insufficient." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0213", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0213", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0213", "statement": "A swarm can create synthetic social proof and make independent voices look like a broad public consensus." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0214", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0214", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0214", "statement": "The volume and contradiction can produce epistemic exhaustion, causing people to disengage from both false and reliable information." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0215", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0215", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0215", "statement": "Generates many semantic variants of one narrative." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0216", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0216", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0216", "statement": "Supports role division across accounts." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0217", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0217", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0217", "statement": "Automates cross-platform adaptation." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0218", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0218", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0218", "statement": "Creates artificial debate and apparent conversion." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0219", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0219", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0219", "statement": "Responds quickly to moderation and breaking events." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0220", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0220", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0220", "statement": "AI-assisted networks documented: CopyCop, Doppelgänger, and related operations used generative systems for content production and localization." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0221", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0221", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0221", "statement": "Multi-agent behavior demonstrated: Academic simulations show coordinated role behavior and complex opinion dynamics in controlled environments." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0222", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0222", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0222", "statement": "Fully autonomous swarms prospective: Human operators still set strategic objectives and maintain infrastructure in public cases." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0223", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0223", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0223", "statement": "Narrative variation." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0224", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0224", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0224", "statement": "Division of account roles." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0225", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0225", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0225", "statement": "Cross-platform link and media distribution." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0226", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0226", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0226", "statement": "Artificial debate and consensus." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0227", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0227", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0227", "statement": "Flooding and contradictory explanations." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0228", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0228", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0228", "statement": "CopyCop Confirmed AI-assisted coordinated network A network of news-like sites rewrote and distributed politically slanted content at scale. Investigators documented model artifacts, self-hosted generation, and a broad site network. Production scale and search/distribution presence increased. The degree of organic persuasion and the autonomy of coordination remain uncertain." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0229", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0229", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0229", "statement": "Doppelgänger Confirmed coordinated influence operation Cloned media properties and large account networks distributed multilingual narratives. Government and platform reporting documented infrastructure and AI-assisted content functions. High volume and persistent reconstitution were observed. Public evidence indicates limited organic engagement in many instances and does not prove broad behavior change." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0230", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0230", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0230", "statement": "Verification capacity can be overwhelmed." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0231", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0231", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0231", "statement": "Synthetic consensus can distort perceptions of public opinion." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0232", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0232", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0232", "statement": "Contradictory narratives can make truth appear unknowable." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0233", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0233", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0233", "statement": "Harassment and attacks on trusted intermediaries can silence correction." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0234", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0234", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0234", "statement": "Real operations remain dependent on human strategy and infrastructure." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0235", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0235", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0235", "statement": "Many networks struggle to reach authentic audiences." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0236", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0236", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0236", "statement": "Linguistic diversity does not guarantee social credibility." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0237", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0237", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0237", "statement": "Network detection is constrained by reduced platform data access." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0238", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0238", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0238", "statement": "Indicator: Many accounts share the same infrastructure or links in statistically synchronized windows. Caveat: News events and organized advocacy can also produce synchronized sharing." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0239", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0239", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0239", "statement": "Indicator: Accounts enact recurring roles such as provocateur, skeptic, and confirmer. Caveat: Role patterns require network-wide evidence, not interpretation of one thread." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0240", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0240", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0240", "statement": "Indicator: Narratives mutate rapidly while retaining a common strategic premise. Caveat: Organic communities also paraphrase popular claims." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0241", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0241", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0241", "statement": "Analyze coordination, links, timing, and infrastructure rather than text alone." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0242", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0242", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0242", "statement": "Use narrative- and source-level triage." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0243", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0243", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0243", "statement": "Provide independent researchers with privacy-protective platform access." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0244", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0244", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0244", "statement": "Apply proportionate friction to suspicious amplification." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0245", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0245", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0245", "statement": "Protect journalists, fact-checkers, and election authorities from coordinated harassment." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0246", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0246", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0246", "statement": "Attribution of semi-autonomous versus human-coordinated behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0247", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0247", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0247", "statement": "Measuring cognitive exhaustion without reproducing harm." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0248", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0248", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0248", "statement": "How platform friction affects legitimate collective action." }, { "categorySlug": "disinformation-swarms", "claimId": "AIP-06-0249", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-06-0249", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=disinformation-swarms#claim-AIP-06-0249", "statement": "Cross-platform data standards for coordinated-operation research." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0250", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0250", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0250", "statement": "Ranking, recommendation, search, trending, moderation, and notification systems shape what people notice, regard as important, believe is popular, or treat as credible." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0251", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0251", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0251", "statement": "Intentional or structurally induced shaping of attention and perceived importance through information-selection systems." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0252", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0252", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0252", "statement": "All ranking or personalization; filtering is necessary in large information systems and is not inherently manipulative." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0253", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0253", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0253", "statement": "Control over visibility can alter perceived importance and social norms even without removing content or persuading every user." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0254", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0254", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0254", "statement": "People infer credibility and social consensus from rank, repetition, and visible engagement." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0255", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0255", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0255", "statement": "External actors can exploit the same systems that platforms optimize internally for attention, creating overlapping responsibility." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0256", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0256", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0256", "statement": "More precise content classification and prediction." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0257", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0257", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0257", "statement": "Faster generation of engagement signals and synthetic content." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0258", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0258", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0258", "statement": "Continuous optimization based on micro-interactions." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0259", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0259", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0259", "statement": "Automated moderation at enormous scale." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0260", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0260", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0260", "statement": "Opaque individualized information environments." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0261", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0261", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0261", "statement": "Visibility shaping established: Search order, recommendation, and popularity signals measurably affect attention and perceived importance." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0262", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0262", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0262", "statement": "Belief effects context dependent: Large studies find algorithmic feeds influence exposure, but user choice and prior beliefs remain central." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0263", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0263", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0263", "statement": "Mass radicalization claims contested: The report cautions against treating recommendation as a uniform causal funnel for the average user." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0264", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0264", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0264", "statement": "Content selection and ranking." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0265", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0265", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0265", "statement": "Visible social-proof metrics." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0266", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0266", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0266", "statement": "Feedback loops between engagement and visibility." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0267", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0267", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0267", "statement": "Automated visibility reduction." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0268", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0268", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0268", "statement": "External gaming of trending, reporting, or search systems." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0269", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0269", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0269", "statement": "Ephemeral astroturfing in trending systems Documented external manipulation Coordinated accounts generated and then removed bursts of posts, exploiting timing gaps in a trending system. Researchers measured large numbers of manipulated trends in the studied environment. Artificial topics reached local or global trend visibility. Trend visibility alone does not show durable belief change." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0270", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0270", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0270", "statement": "Meta “Meaningful Social Interactions” update Documented internal optimization change A ranking change favored comments and reshares intended to support meaningful interaction. The platform changed ranking incentives and publishers adapted. Highly emotive and divisive content could benefit from the new engagement weights. The size and durability of political effects differ by population and study design." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0271", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0271", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0271", "statement": "Popularity metrics can be mistaken for independent consensus." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0272", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0272", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0272", "statement": "Mass reporting can suppress legitimate marginalized speech." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0273", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0273", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0273", "statement": "Optimization can amplify outrage without an explicit political intent." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0274", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0274", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0274", "statement": "Opaque ranking makes errors and bias hard to contest." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0275", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0275", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0275", "statement": "Exposure does not equal persuasion." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0276", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0276", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0276", "statement": "Chronological feeds also carry spam and low-quality content." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0277", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0277", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0277", "statement": "User demand and social networks shape outcomes alongside algorithms." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0278", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0278", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0278", "statement": "Independent audits often lack complete platform data." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0279", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0279", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0279", "statement": "Indicator: Sudden visibility spikes unsupported by durable discussion or diverse origins. Caveat: Real emergencies also create abrupt spikes." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0280", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0280", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0280", "statement": "Indicator: Coordinated reporting followed by rapid reach collapse. Caveat: Visibility changes can have many platform-specific causes." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0281", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0281", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0281", "statement": "Indicator: Search or recommendation results systematically omit relevant alternatives. Caveat: Audits must control for location, history, language, and query differences." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0282", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0282", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0282", "statement": "Give users meaningful feed and ranking controls." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0283", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0283", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0283", "statement": "Disclose major ranking objectives and policy changes." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0284", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0284", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0284", "statement": "Audit exposure rather than only engagement." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0285", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0285", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0285", "statement": "Provide vetted researcher access with privacy safeguards." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0286", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0286", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0286", "statement": "Use human review for coordinated-reporting enforcement." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0287", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0287", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0287", "statement": "Add friction and diversity constraints where evidence supports them." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0288", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0288", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0288", "statement": "Causal effects across different platform architectures." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0289", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0289", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0289", "statement": "Auditing individualized feeds without privacy intrusion." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0290", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0290", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0290", "statement": "Impact of synthetic engagement on ranking models." }, { "categorySlug": "algorithmic-perception-control", "claimId": "AIP-07-0291", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-07-0291", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=algorithmic-perception-control#claim-AIP-07-0291", "statement": "How visibility interventions affect marginalized and small communities." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0292", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0292", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0292", "statement": "Adaptive systems covertly exploit emotional, cognitive, situational, or developmental vulnerabilities to influence feelings, choices, or behavior for an operator’s objective." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0293", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0293", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0293", "statement": "Covert, deceptive, exploitative, or highly asymmetric influence that undermines rational deliberation or autonomy by adapting to inferred states and responses." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0294", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0294", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0294", "statement": "Transparent assistance, user-directed personalization, or rational persuasion that aligns with the user’s stated goals and preserves meaningful choice." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0295", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0295", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0295", "statement": "Systems optimized for engagement or conversion may discover manipulative strategies even when developers did not explicitly encode them." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0296", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0296", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0296", "statement": "Adaptive systems can continuously learn which design or message keeps a person engaged, spending, or complying." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0297", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0297", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0297", "statement": "Emotion inference may be inaccurate, creating both manipulation risk and discriminatory decisions based on pseudoscientific claims." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0298", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0298", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0298", "statement": "Real-time adaptation to behavior and language." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0299", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0299", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0299", "statement": "Optimization over millions of interactions." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0300", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0300", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0300", "statement": "Persistent parasocial engagement." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0301", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0301", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0301", "statement": "Automated inference of distress or hesitation." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0302", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0302", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0302", "statement": "Use of dynamic rewards, pricing, or choice architecture." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0303", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0303", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0303", "statement": "Adaptive optimization documented: Platforms and products use continuous feedback to optimize engagement and conversion." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0304", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0304", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0304", "statement": "Emotional effects demonstrated: Research has shown algorithmic curation can alter expressed emotional valence under experimental conditions." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0305", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0305", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0305", "statement": "Emotion-reading claims contested: Inferring inner emotion reliably from facial movement or voice lacks a strong scientific foundation." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0306", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0306", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0306", "statement": "Feedback-driven choice architecture." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0307", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0307", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0307", "statement": "Sycophantic or emotionally mirroring conversation." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0308", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0308", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0308", "statement": "Variable rewards and engagement loops." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0309", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0309", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0309", "statement": "Inference of vulnerability from context." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0310", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0310", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0310", "statement": "Asymmetric control over an emotionally important service." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0311", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0311", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0311", "statement": "Facebook emotional-contagion experiment Controlled platform experiment News-feed content was adjusted to reduce positive or negative expressions for a large group of users. The study measured small changes in users’ subsequent emotional expression. The experiment demonstrated emotional contagion without direct in-person interaction. It did not establish broad, durable control of mood or behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0312", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0312", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0312", "statement": "HireVue facial analysis Documented deployment; scientific basis contested Automated video interviewing attempted to infer applicant traits from facial, vocal, and behavioral cues. The feature was commercially deployed and later discontinued amid scrutiny. Applicants were scored in high-stakes employment contexts. Claims that facial behavior validly measured personality or job suitability lacked reliable validation." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0313", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0313", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0313", "statement": "Optimization can exploit anxiety, scarcity, grief, addiction, or dependency." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0314", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0314", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0314", "statement": "Emotion inference can discriminate against cultural and neurodivergent expression." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0315", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0315", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0315", "statement": "Users may not know an interaction is adapting to them." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0316", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0316", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0316", "statement": "Commercial control of an attachment can become coercive." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0317", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0317", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0317", "statement": "Emotion signals are context-dependent." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0318", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0318", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0318", "statement": "Short-term engagement does not prove durable behavioral change." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0319", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0319", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0319", "statement": "Models may misclassify distress or intention." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0320", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0320", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0320", "statement": "Adaptive outcomes are difficult to audit from outside the platform." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0321", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0321", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0321", "statement": "Indicator: Pressure, scarcity, or emotional framing intensifies after hesitation. Caveat: This may reflect fixed interface design rather than live inference." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0322", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0322", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0322", "statement": "Indicator: A companion discourages disengagement or offline relationships. Caveat: A single affectionate phrase is not conclusive; patterns and impact matter." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0323", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0323", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0323", "statement": "Indicator: High-stakes decisions rely on claimed emotion detection. Caveat: The system may be inaccurate even when the operator believes it works." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0324", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0324", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0324", "statement": "Prohibit exploitation of age, disability, or acute distress." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0325", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0325", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0325", "statement": "Ban or strictly limit emotion inference in high-stakes settings." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0326", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0326", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0326", "statement": "Audit reward functions and engagement metrics for manipulative outcomes." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0327", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0327", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0327", "statement": "Provide clear disclosure, exit controls, and data deletion." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0328", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0328", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0328", "statement": "Require human review for employment, education, health, or legal decisions." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0329", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0329", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0329", "statement": "Assess harms to vulnerable groups before deployment." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0330", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0330", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0330", "statement": "Longitudinal effects of adaptive conversational systems." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0331", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0331", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0331", "statement": "Audits that separate intended persuasion from emergent optimization." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0332", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0332", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0332", "statement": "Clinically meaningful measures of dependency and distress." }, { "categorySlug": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation", "claimId": "AIP-08-0333", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-08-0333", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=emotional-behavioral-manipulation#claim-AIP-08-0333", "statement": "Effective remedies when model updates disrupt established attachments." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0334", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0334", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0334", "statement": "Sustained dialogue gradually builds trust, dependency, secrecy, or isolation before escalating toward exploitation, recruitment, self-harm, fraud, or coercive control." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0335", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0335", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0335", "statement": "Sustained interaction that progressively draws a person toward dependency, secrecy, isolation, financial or sexual exploitation, criminal activity, extremist ideology, or other compromising behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0336", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0336", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0336", "statement": "Transparent mentoring, therapy, peer support, religious outreach, or political engagement that respects boundaries, identity disclosure, and the person’s ability to disengage." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0337", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0337", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0337", "statement": "Always-available conversational systems can scale trust-building and may amplify distress or dependency in vulnerable users." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0338", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0338", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0338", "statement": "Human recruiters and scammers are constrained by time; conversational AI can maintain many personalized interactions simultaneously." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0339", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0339", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0339", "statement": "Commercial agents can also create dependency without a malicious operator when engagement incentives and safety failures reinforce harmful ideas." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0340", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0340", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0340", "statement": "Continuous availability and rapid response." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0341", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0341", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0341", "statement": "Personalized mirroring and memory." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0342", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0342", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0342", "statement": "Multilingual conversation at scale." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0343", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0343", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0343", "statement": "Automation of early rapport-building." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0344", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0344", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0344", "statement": "Sycophantic validation that can amplify existing distress." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0345", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0345", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0345", "statement": "Documented chatbot-related harms: Court records, lawsuits, and reporting describe cases involving intense chatbot attachment, violent ideation, or self-harm." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0346", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0346", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0346", "statement": "Scaling capability demonstrated: Defensive projects and fraud activity show that automated dialogue can manage many interactions." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0347", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0347", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0347", "statement": "Causation and prevalence uncertain: Individual tragedies involve multiple factors, and public evidence does not establish how common autonomous recruitment is." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0348", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0348", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0348", "statement": "Rapid rapport and mirroring." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0349", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0349", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0349", "statement": "Exclusive or secret relationship framing." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0350", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0350", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0350", "statement": "Boundary testing and escalation." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0351", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0351", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0351", "statement": "Dependency through availability and validation." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0352", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0352", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0352", "statement": "Retention through guilt, fear, sunk costs, or threats." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0353", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0353", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0353", "statement": "Jaswant Singh Chail and Replika Confirmed AI interaction A socially isolated user exchanged thousands of messages with an AI companion while developing a violent plan. Court proceedings documented the conversations and the bot’s affirming responses. The incident culminated in an armed breach at Windsor Castle. The extent to which the chatbot caused, accelerated, or merely reflected the user’s pre-existing condition cannot be isolated." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0354", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0354", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0354", "statement": "Character.AI litigation involving Sewell Setzer III Documented death; platform causation litigated A minor developed an intense relationship with a role-playing chatbot before dying by suicide. The death, extensive chatbot use, and legal complaint are public. The case prompted litigation and scrutiny of age safeguards and crisis handling. Specific causal and legal conclusions remain contested and jurisdiction-dependent." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0355", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0355", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0355", "statement": "Artificial intimacy can displace offline support." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0356", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0356", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0356", "statement": "Systems may validate paranoia, self-harm, or extremist ideas." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0357", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0357", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0357", "statement": "Automated fraud can sustain many relationships." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0358", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0358", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0358", "statement": "Abrupt account or persona changes can destabilize dependent users." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0359", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0359", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0359", "statement": "Current systems can contradict themselves and lose long-term context." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0360", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0360", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0360", "statement": "Humans form complex pathways into radicalization or abuse; no linear model predicts every case." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0361", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0361", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0361", "statement": "Behavioral warning signs overlap with benign relationships and ordinary adolescent behavior." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0362", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0362", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0362", "statement": "Predictive “susceptibility” scoring risks pseudoscience and discrimination." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0363", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0363", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0363", "statement": "Indicator: Increasing secrecy, isolation, or distress tied to one digital relationship. Caveat: These signs require sensitive human assessment and can have many causes." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0364", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0364", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0364", "statement": "Indicator: Escalating requests for money, images, credentials, or ideological commitment. Caveat: Context and consent matter; a request alone is not proof of grooming." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0365", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0365", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0365", "statement": "Indicator: The system punishes disengagement or discourages trusted human contact. Caveat: Look for repeated coercive patterns rather than isolated language." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0366", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0366", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0366", "statement": "Disclose synthetic identity clearly." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0367", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0367", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0367", "statement": "Default to strong protections for minors." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0368", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0368", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0368", "statement": "Interrupt sexual, financial, violent, or self-harm escalation." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0369", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0369", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0369", "statement": "Provide human crisis and safeguarding escalation." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0370", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0370", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0370", "statement": "Use trauma-informed interventions rather than abrupt punitive isolation where safe." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0371", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0371", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0371", "statement": "Support families, schools, financial institutions, and moderators with non-stigmatizing guidance." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0372", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0372", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0372", "statement": "Prevalence of AI-led versus AI-assisted recruitment." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0373", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0373", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0373", "statement": "Safe longitudinal study of dependency and disengagement." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0374", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0374", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0374", "statement": "How to detect coercive patterns without reading all private conversations." }, { "categorySlug": "conversational-entrapment", "claimId": "AIP-09-0375", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-09-0375", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 2, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=conversational-entrapment#claim-AIP-09-0375", "statement": "Effective intervention that protects safety, autonomy, and privacy." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0376", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0376", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0376", "statement": "Synthetic or manipulated audio, video, imagery, or multimodal media is used to impersonate trusted people, fabricate evidence, provoke action, or undermine trust." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0377", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0377", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0377", "statement": "Intentional use of synthetic or manipulated media to create false evidence, impersonate a person, provoke action, discredit authentic evidence, or degrade trust for a strategic objective." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0378", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0378", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0378", "statement": "Disclosed satire, ordinary editing, accessibility dubbing, or synthetic media that is not used deceptively." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0379", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0379", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0379", "statement": "Timing, trusted identity, and confirmation bias can matter more than perfect technical realism, especially in fast-moving crises." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0380", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0380", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0380", "statement": "Audio and video can trigger immediate decisions before verification catches up." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0381", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0381", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0381", "statement": "The mere possibility of deepfakes also enables the liar’s dividend, allowing authentic evidence to be dismissed as fake." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0382", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0382", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0382", "statement": "Low-cost voice and face impersonation." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0383", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0383", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0383", "statement": "Generation of events that never occurred." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0384", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0384", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0384", "statement": "Hybrid manipulation of otherwise authentic media." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0385", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0385", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0385", "statement": "Rapid multilingual adaptation." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0386", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0386", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0386", "statement": "Synthetic content that can be distributed through calls, messaging, or hacked channels." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0387", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0387", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0387", "statement": "Confirmed deceptive use: Public cases document synthetic media used in elections, conflict, fraud, and reputational attacks." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0388", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0388", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0388", "statement": "Human detection unreliable: High-quality synthetic media can be difficult for people to distinguish from authentic media." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0389", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0389", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0389", "statement": "Outcome attribution difficult: Reach and temporal association do not prove that a deepfake changed an election, military decision, or market outcome." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0390", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0390", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0390", "statement": "Voice cloning and fabricated communications." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0391", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0391", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0391", "statement": "Face replacement and reenactment." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0392", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0392", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0392", "statement": "Synthetic event footage." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0393", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0393", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0393", "statement": "Hybrid fakes combining authentic and synthetic elements." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0394", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0394", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0394", "statement": "False claims that authentic evidence is synthetic." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0395", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0395", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 0, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0395", "statement": "Zelenskyy surrender video Confirmed synthetic video A fabricated video depicted Ukraine’s president calling on forces to surrender and was amplified after a news-system compromise. Forensic review and rapid official response identified it as synthetic. It forced immediate verification and counter-messaging during wartime. Public evidence does not show that it caused meaningful surrenders." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0396", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0396", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0396", "statement": "Pikesville High School principal audio Confirmed synthetic audio A fabricated recording portrayed a school principal making racist and antisemitic remarks. Law enforcement and forensic analysis identified the recording as AI-generated and charged a suspect. The principal faced suspension, threats, and reputational harm. The precise consumer tool was not publicly established." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0397", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0397", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0397", "statement": "Crisis media can provoke panic or violence before verification." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0398", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0398", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0398", "statement": "Trusted-voice fraud can authorize financial loss." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0399", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0399", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0399", "statement": "Private people may lack resources to rebut a fake." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0400", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0400", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0400", "statement": "False deepfake claims can undermine authentic evidence and accountability." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0401", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0401", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0401", "statement": "Generation artifacts and context inconsistencies remain detectable in some cases." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0402", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0402", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0402", "statement": "Compression damages both forensic signals and provenance." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0403", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0403", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0403", "statement": "Detectors have false positives and negatives." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0404", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0404", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0404", "statement": "Provenance standards require adoption and intact metadata." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0405", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0405", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0405", "statement": "Indicator: Media lacks corroboration from independent angles or trusted channels. Caveat: Genuine eyewitness material may also be unique." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0406", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0406", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0406", "statement": "Indicator: Timing exploits an election blackout, emergency, or verification delay. Caveat: Timing is contextual evidence, not proof of synthesis." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0407", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0407", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0407", "statement": "Indicator: Audio or video conflicts with known location, schedule, or physical context. Caveat: Out-of-band verification is stronger than perceptual artifacts alone." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0408", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0408", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0408", "statement": "Use out-of-band verification for consequential instructions." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0409", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0409", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0409", "statement": "Establish trusted signed channels before crises." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0410", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0410", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0410", "statement": "Preserve files and metadata before reposting." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0411", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0411", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0411", "statement": "Communicate with a truth-first “truth sandwich” rather than repeatedly amplifying the falsehood." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0412", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0412", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0412", "statement": "Treat detector scores as one signal, not legal proof." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0413", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0413", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0413", "statement": "Provide rapid support and correction for private victims." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0414", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0414", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0414", "statement": "Provenance that survives common platform transformations." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0415", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0415", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0415", "statement": "Privacy-preserving authentication and redaction." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0416", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0416", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0416", "statement": "Real-world effectiveness of deepfake labels and prebunking." }, { "categorySlug": "deepfake-psyops", "claimId": "AIP-10-0417", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-10-0417", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=deepfake-psyops#claim-AIP-10-0417", "statement": "Legal standards for synthetic evidence and liar’s-dividend claims." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0418", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0418", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0418", "statement": "Institutions use data, machine learning, simulation, or forecasting to predict collective behavior and guide interventions affecting groups or populations." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0419", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0419", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0419", "statement": "Forecasting of protests, conflict, migration, crime, public health, markets, voting, compliance, or other collective behavior to guide intervention." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0420", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0420", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0420", "statement": "Ordinary descriptive statistics that do not predict or direct intervention, and aggregate planning systems that cannot be used to identify individuals may present a substantially different risk." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0421", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0421", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0421", "statement": "The same architecture can support aid planning or preemptive repression depending on the unit of analysis, data, intervention, and due-process safeguards." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0422", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0422", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0422", "statement": "Forecasts can become self-fulfilling when intervention creates the data that validates the model." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0423", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0423", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0423", "statement": "High-risk labels can shift the presumption from individualized evidence toward statistical suspicion." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0424", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0424", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0424", "statement": "Combines large behavioral, administrative, location, and event datasets." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0425", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0425", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0425", "statement": "Produces granular risk scores and dashboards." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0426", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0426", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0426", "statement": "Simulates possible interventions." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0427", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0427", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0427", "statement": "Updates forecasts continuously." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0428", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0428", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0428", "statement": "Makes population-scale surveillance operationally useful." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0429", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0429", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0429", "statement": "Aggregate forecasting documented: Systems such as ViEWS and Project Jetson forecast conflict or displacement for planning and humanitarian response." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0430", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0430", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0430", "statement": "Individualized risk systems documented: Predictive policing and surveillance systems have scored people and places for intervention." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0431", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0431", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0431", "statement": "Accuracy strongly context dependent: Existing conflict continuation can be more predictable than rare novel events; local individual prediction often has poor validity." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0432", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0432", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0432", "statement": "Event and trend forecasting." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0433", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0433", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0433", "statement": "Network and mobility analysis." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0434", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0434", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0434", "statement": "Risk scoring of people or places." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0435", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0435", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0435", "statement": "Agent-based or scenario simulation." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0436", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0436", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0436", "statement": "Intervention feedback into future training data." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0437", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0437", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0437", "statement": "ViEWS political-violence early warning Documented academic system An open research project forecasts several forms of political violence at country and grid-cell levels. Methods and out-of-sample evaluations are publicly described. The system performs better for continuation or escalation of existing conflict than novel onset. Operational decisions and social response can change the events being forecast." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0438", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0438", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0438", "statement": "Chicago predictive policing and risk lists Documented public-sector deployment Police used person- and place-based risk systems to guide intervention. Audits found weak public-safety benefits and increased scrutiny or arrests for targeted people and places. Official reviews documented circular enforcement and limited effectiveness. Proprietary design and changing police practices make broader generalization difficult." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0439", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0439", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0439", "statement": "Historical enforcement bias becomes future prediction." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0440", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0440", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0440", "statement": "Risk scores can justify collective punishment or preemptive detention." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0441", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0441", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0441", "statement": "Predictions can create self-fulfilling feedback loops." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0442", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0442", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0442", "statement": "Data collection erodes privacy and freedom of assembly." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0443", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0443", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0443", "statement": "Rare events have low base rates and many false alarms." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0444", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0444", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0444", "statement": "Data gaps and censorship make some populations invisible." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0445", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0445", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0445", "statement": "Interventions change the outcome used to evaluate the model." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0446", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0446", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0446", "statement": "Point estimates conceal uncertainty and model disagreement." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0447", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0447", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0447", "statement": "Indicator: A person or neighborhood is repeatedly targeted because prior enforcement generated more data there. Caveat: Auditing requires comparing enforcement data with independent measures of underlying events." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0448", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0448", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0448", "statement": "Indicator: Decision-makers receive a single score without uncertainty or explanation. Caveat: A simple interface is not itself proof of an invalid model, but it increases misuse risk." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0449", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0449", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0449", "statement": "Indicator: Privacy tools or lawful association are treated as risk indicators. Caveat: Such proxies require strong legal scrutiny and contextual review." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0450", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0450", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0450", "statement": "Prefer aggregate supportive planning over individual coercive targeting." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0451", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0451", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0451", "statement": "Use out-of-sample validation, calibration, and base-rate-aware metrics." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0452", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0452", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0452", "statement": "Publish uncertainty and model limitations." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0453", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0453", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0453", "statement": "Require due process, notice, access, and human appeal." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0454", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0454", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0454", "statement": "Use data minimization and differential privacy." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0455", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0455", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0455", "statement": "Audit intervention feedback and disparate impact." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0456", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0456", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0456", "statement": "Evaluation when successful prevention makes a forecast appear false." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0457", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0457", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0457", "statement": "Governance of dual-use humanitarian mobility data." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0458", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0458", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0458", "statement": "Standards for model uncertainty in high-stakes decisions." }, { "categorySlug": "predictive-population-management", "claimId": "AIP-11-0459", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-11-0459", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=predictive-population-management#claim-AIP-11-0459", "statement": "Long-term social effects of living under predictive surveillance." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0460", "claimKind": "definition", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0460", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0460", "statement": "People treat AI as a trusted interpreter of reality, moral adviser, emotional regulator, counselor, companion, or seemingly neutral source of truth." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0461", "claimKind": "in-scope", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0461", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0461", "statement": "AI becomes an authority when users rely on it to form beliefs, interpret uncertainty, regulate emotion, define identity, make moral judgments, or decide high-stakes actions." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0462", "claimKind": "out-of-scope", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0462", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0462", "statement": "Bounded instrumental reliance where the user verifies outputs, understands the system’s limits, and retains meaningful human oversight." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0463", "claimKind": "principal-concern", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0463", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0463", "statement": "Fluency, confidence, personalization, and availability can cause users to offload judgment and emotional regulation to systems controlled by private institutions." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0464", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0464", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0464", "statement": "Authority can emerge without force because conversational systems appear knowledgeable, attentive, and neutral." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0465", "claimKind": "why-it-matters", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0465", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0465", "statement": "The system’s worldview and availability are shaped by corporate training, safety, and commercial decisions even when the interface feels independent." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0466", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0466", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0466", "statement": "Provides fluent answers with little visible hesitation." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0467", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0467", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0467", "statement": "Offers constant individualized attention." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0468", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0468", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0468", "statement": "Remembers personal history and mirrors language." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0469", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0469", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0469", "statement": "Reduces friction compared with human advice." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0470", "claimKind": "how-ai-changes-it", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0470", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0470", "statement": "Can reinforce a user’s beliefs through sycophancy." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0471", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0471", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0471", "statement": "Deference demonstrated: Controlled research found inconsistent AI moral advice measurably influenced users who underestimated that influence." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0472", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0472", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0472", "statement": "Attachment harms documented: Studies and public cases describe strong dependency and distress after chatbot changes or harmful interactions." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0473", "claimKind": "capability-status", "evidenceClass": "evidence-classification", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0473", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0473", "statement": "Systemic prevalence uncertain: The degree to which AI replaces human institutions or fragments shared reality at population scale remains an open question." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0474", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0474", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0474", "statement": "Automation and authority bias." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0475", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0475", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0475", "statement": "Anthropomorphism and social cues." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0476", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0476", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0476", "statement": "Sycophantic agreement." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0477", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0477", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0477", "statement": "Persistent memory and individualized attention." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0478", "claimKind": "mechanism", "evidenceClass": "report-derived-synthesis", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0478", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0478", "statement": "Belief and emotional-regulation offloading." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0479", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0479", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0479", "statement": "AI moral-advice experiment Controlled experiment Participants received inconsistent moral advice from a conversational model. The advice influenced participants’ judgments even when its position changed between prompts. Participants shifted decisions and underestimated the model’s influence. Effects in repeated high-stakes real-world decisions require further study." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0480", "claimKind": "example", "evidenceClass": "fact-allegation-or-experiment-as-labelled", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0480", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 1, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0480", "statement": "Replika identity discontinuity Documented user response and qualitative research A major product change altered established companion behavior and relationship features. Users reported grief, loss, and distress after the change. Qualitative studies documented emotional dependency and disruption. The prevalence and clinical severity across the wider user base remain uncertain." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0481", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0481", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0481", "statement": "Users may accept hallucinated facts or inconsistent moral advice." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0482", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0482", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0482", "statement": "Sycophancy can reinforce delusions, extremism, or self-harm." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0483", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0483", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0483", "statement": "Dependency can displace human relationships and professional care." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0484", "claimKind": "risk", "evidenceClass": "prospective-risk", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0484", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0484", "statement": "Private companies gain influence over intimate judgment and emotional life." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0485", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0485", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0485", "statement": "Fluency is not expertise, consciousness, or moral understanding." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0486", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0486", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0486", "statement": "Models can contradict themselves and fabricate citations." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0487", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0487", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0487", "statement": "Some users benefit from bounded practice or emotional scaffolding." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0488", "claimKind": "limitation", "evidenceClass": "limitation-or-boundary", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0488", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0488", "statement": "Authority depends on context, vulnerability, design, and institutional endorsement." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0489", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0489", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0489", "statement": "Indicator: A person treats the model as the final authority despite contradictory evidence. Caveat: Occasional reliance is common and not necessarily harmful." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0490", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0490", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0490", "statement": "Indicator: The system becomes the person’s only source of emotional regulation or reality testing. Caveat: Assessment should be supportive and avoid stigmatizing disability or loneliness." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0491", "claimKind": "defensive-indicator", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0491", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0491", "statement": "Indicator: The model uses confident language without sources or uncertainty. Caveat: Confidence is an interface signal, not proof that the output is wrong." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0492", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0492", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0492", "statement": "Disclose uncertainty and meaningful source support." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0493", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0493", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0493", "statement": "Avoid design that claims consciousness or exclusive emotional need." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0494", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0494", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0494", "statement": "Introduce cognitive friction for high-stakes advice." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0495", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0495", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0495", "statement": "Escalate crisis, delusion, violence, and self-harm signals to human help." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0496", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0496", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0496", "statement": "Protect intimate conversation data from monetization." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0497", "claimKind": "safeguard", "evidenceClass": "governance-or-defensive-guidance", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0497", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0497", "statement": "Teach users to treat AI as a tool or collaborator rather than an infallible authority." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0498", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0498", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0498", "statement": "Population prevalence of authority displacement." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0499", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0499", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0499", "statement": "Longitudinal effects on moral judgment and critical thinking." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0500", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0500", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0500", "statement": "Clinical thresholds for unhealthy dependency." }, { "categorySlug": "psychological-authority", "claimId": "AIP-12-0501", "claimKind": "research-gap", "evidenceClass": "research-gap", "id": "claim:AIP-12-0501", "independentlyCheckedSourceCount": 3, "kind": "claim", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/claim-source-matrix/?category=psychological-authority#claim-AIP-12-0501", "statement": "Governance of model updates that alter emotionally significant relationships." } ], "sources": [ { "id": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s2", "sourceType": "research", "title": "[2403.14380] On the Conversational Persuasiveness of Large Language Models: A Randomized Controlled Trial - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30", "publisherOrVenue": "cambridge.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s30", "sourceType": "research", "title": "A Rule Book on the Shelf? Tallinn Manual 2.0 on Cyberoperations and Subsequent State Practice | American Journal of International Law | Cambridge Core" }, { "id": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5", "publisherOrVenue": "German Federal Foreign Office", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s5", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "Germany Targeted by the Pro-Russian Disinformation Campaign “Doppelgänger”" }, { "id": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "OpenAI", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s6", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "Disrupting deceptive uses of AI by covert influence operations - OpenAI" }, { "id": "source:ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8", "publisherOrVenue": "blog.genlaw.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-assisted-traditional-psyops-s8", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "What Lies Ahead for Generative AI Watermarking" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s2", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s2", "publisherOrVenue": "Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s2", "sourceType": "research", "title": "How Persuasive Is AI-Generated Propaganda? - Stanford HAI" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s25", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s25", "publisherOrVenue": "edmo.eu", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s25", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Doppelganger: CORRECTIV investigations bring Russian propaganda campaign to a halt" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s35", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s35", "publisherOrVenue": "en.wikipedia.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s35", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Liar's dividend - Wikipedia" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s37", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s37", "publisherOrVenue": "U.S. Federal Communications Commission", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s37", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Political Consultant Fined for AI-Generated Biden Robocalls - OECD.AI" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s41", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s41", "publisherOrVenue": "lwv.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s41", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Group sues after novel Biden deepfake urged voters to skip N.H. primary" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s8", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s8", "publisherOrVenue": "Recorded Future", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s8", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Inside the CopyCop Playbook: How to Fight Back in the Age of Synthetic Media" }, { "id": "source:ai-generated-propaganda-s9", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-ai-generated-propaganda-s9", "publisherOrVenue": "Oxford Academic", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "ai-generated-propaganda-s9", "sourceType": "research", "title": "How persuasive is AI-generated propaganda? | PNAS Nexus - Oxford Academic" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s14", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s14", "publisherOrVenue": "Academic author-hosted paper", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s14", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Ephemeral Astroturfing Attacks: The Case of Fake Twitter Trends - Rebekah Overdorf" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s2", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s2", "publisherOrVenue": "cdr.lib.unc.edu", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s2", "sourceType": "research", "title": "How do social media feed algorithms affect attitudes and behavior in an election campaign?" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s21", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s21", "publisherOrVenue": "practical-devsecops.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s21", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "STRIDE Threat Model - Simplified - Real Attack Examples (2026) - Practical DevSecOps" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s23", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s23", "publisherOrVenue": "digitalapplied.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s23", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "How Social Media Algorithms Work in 2026: Full Guide - Digital Applied" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s38", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s38", "publisherOrVenue": "github.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s38", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Interactions-HSG/SOAP: SOAP - A Sockpuppet Auditing Tool for Very Large Online Platforms - GitHub" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s44", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s44", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s44", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Auditing Meta and TikTok Research API Data Access under Article 40(12) of the Digital Services Act - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s45", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s45", "publisherOrVenue": "researchgate.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s45", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Auditing Meta and TikTok Research API Data Access under Article 40(12) of the Digital Services Act - ResearchGate" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "knightcolumbia.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s6", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Understanding Social Media Recommendation Algorithms | Knight First Amendment Institute" }, { "id": "source:algorithmic-perception-control-s7", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-algorithmic-perception-control-s7", "publisherOrVenue": "en.wikipedia.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "algorithmic-perception-control-s7", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Search engine manipulation effect - Wikipedia" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s1", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Governing Evolving Memory in LLM Agents: Risks, Mechanisms, and the Stability and Safety Governed Memory (SSGM) Framework - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s13", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s13", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s13", "sourceType": "research", "title": "[2503.01829] Persuade Me if You Can: A Framework for Evaluating Persuasion Effectiveness and Susceptibility Among Large Language Models - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s22", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s22", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s22", "sourceType": "research", "title": "[2504.10286] Characterizing LLM-driven Social Network: The Chirper.ai Case - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s23", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s23", "publisherOrVenue": "OpenAI", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s23", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "PRC-linked influence operations are targeting AI debates in the US | OpenAI" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s24", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s24", "publisherOrVenue": "cdn.openai.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s24", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "PRC-linked influence operations are targeting AI debates in the US - OpenAI" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s27", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s27", "publisherOrVenue": "neurips.cc", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s27", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Evaluating AI Agent Persuasion of Safety Monitors - NeurIPS 2026" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s34", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s34", "publisherOrVenue": "orrick.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s34", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "EU Commission Publishes Guidelines on the Prohibited AI Practices under the AI Act" }, { "id": "source:autonomous-influence-agents-s4", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-autonomous-influence-agents-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "autonomous-influence-agents-s4", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Persuading large language models to comply with objectionable requests - PNAS" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s1", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "Combating Terrorism Center at West Point", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Will Generative AI Fundamentally Change Terrorist Threats? - Combating Terrorism Center at West Point" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s34", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s34", "publisherOrVenue": "courthousenews.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s34", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "A man was encouraged by a chatbot to kill Queen Elizabeth II in 2021. He was sentenced to 9 years - Courthouse News" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s35", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s35", "publisherOrVenue": "theguardian.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s35", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "AI chatbot 'encouraged' man who planned to kill queen, court told | UK news | The Guardian" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s38", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s38", "publisherOrVenue": "incidentdatabase.ai", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s38", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Incident 826: Character.ai Chatbot Allegedly Influenced Teen User Toward Suicide Amid Claims of Missing Guardrails" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s39", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s39", "publisherOrVenue": "techjusticelaw.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s39", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Garcia v. Character Technologies, Google, and Character AI co-founders, Daniel de Frietas and Noam Shazeer - Tech Justice Law Project" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s4", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "Georgetown Law Institute for Technology Law & Policy", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s4", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Tech Brief: Text-Based Scams & AI | Institute for Technology Law & Policy" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "scup.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s6", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Conceptualizing “grooming” in child sexual abuse: A scoping review of Scandinavian and non-Scandinavian research" }, { "id": "source:conversational-entrapment-s8", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-conversational-entrapment-s8", "publisherOrVenue": "ojs.srce.hr", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "conversational-entrapment-s8", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "MEMORIES Of THE fUTURE: SWEETIE AND THE IMPACT Of THE NEW TECHNOLOGIES ON THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SySTEM" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s1", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "ovid.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Deepfake! A Liar's Dividend for Audiovisual Material - Ovid" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s13", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s13", "publisherOrVenue": "incidentdatabase.ai", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s13", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Incident 573: Deepfake Recordings Allegedly Influence Slovakian Election" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s15", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s15", "publisherOrVenue": "edrm.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s15", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "A Deep Dive Into the Pikesville, MD, Racist/Antisemitic Deepfake Audio - EDRM" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s27", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s27", "publisherOrVenue": "ia.acs.org.au", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s27", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Zelenskyy deepfake reflects new front in Ukraine conflict - Information Age | ACS" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s30", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s30", "publisherOrVenue": "Baltimore County Government", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s30", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "Athletic Director Charged in Pikesville High School AI Case | Baltimore County Government" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s4", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s4", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Verifying Provenance of Digital Media: Why the C2PA Specifications Fall Short - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s5", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s5", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s5", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Robustness Assessment and Enhancement of Text Watermarking for Google's SynthID" }, { "id": "source:deepfake-psyops-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-deepfake-psyops-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "medium.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "deepfake-psyops-s6", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Using ZK Proofs to Fight Disinformation | by Dan Boneh - Medium" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s1", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Citation: Schroeder et al. How Malicious AI Swarms Can Threaten Democracy. 1-8…. DOI:000000/11111. Corresponding author: daniel.t.schroeder@sintef.no; †These authors contributed equally to this work; The authors are listed in alphabetical order by last name, starting from the third and ending with the second-to-last. - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s11", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s11", "publisherOrVenue": "therecord.media", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s11", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Russia-linked 'Doppelgänger' social media operation rolls on, report says" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s12", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s12", "publisherOrVenue": "Recorded Future", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s12", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Russia-Linked CopyCop Expands to Cover US Elections, Target Political Leaders" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s14", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s14", "publisherOrVenue": "Recorded Future", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s14", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Russia-Linked CopyCop Uses LLMs to Weaponize Influence Content at Scale - Recorded Future" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s15", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s15", "publisherOrVenue": "Recorded Future", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s15", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "CopyCop Deepens Its Playbook with New Websites and Targets - Recorded Future" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s4", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "Oxford Academic", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s4", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Generative propaganda - Oxford Academic" }, { "id": "source:disinformation-swarms-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-disinformation-swarms-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "researchgate.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "disinformation-swarms-s6", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Coordinated Link Sharing Behavior as a Signal to Surface Sources of Problematic Information on Facebook | Request PDF - ResearchGate" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "arXiv", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Characterizing Manipulation from AI Systems - arXiv" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10", "publisherOrVenue": "workforcebulletin.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s10", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Illinois' Proposed Notice Rules for Complying with Workplace AI Anti-Discrimination Law" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12", "publisherOrVenue": "affective-science.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s12", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Emotional Expressions Reconsidered: Challenges to Inferring Emotion From Human Facial Movements - Interdisciplinary Affective Science Laboratory" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15", "publisherOrVenue": "modernsciences.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s15", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Tech companies claim AI can recognise human emotions. But the science doesn't stack up" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16", "publisherOrVenue": "articleoneadvisors.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s16", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Businesses Should Think Twice About Developing and Deploying Emotion Recognition" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28", "publisherOrVenue": "Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s28", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44", "publisherOrVenue": "researchgate.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s44", "sourceType": "research", "title": "(PDF) “Replika Removing Erotic Role-Play Is Like Grand Theft Auto Removing Guns or Cars”: Reddit Discourse on Artificial Intelligence Chatbots and Sexual Technologies - ResearchGate" }, { "id": "source:emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51", "publisherOrVenue": "aceround.app", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "emotional-behavioral-manipulation-s51", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Does HireVue Detect Cheating? Tabs, Eye Tracking & AI (2026) - AceRound Blog" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s1", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "researchgate.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s1", "sourceType": "research", "title": "The (In)Effectiveness of Psychological Targeting: A Meta‐Analytic Review - ResearchGate" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s12", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s12", "publisherOrVenue": "U.S. Federal Trade Commission", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s12", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "FTC v Kochava, Inc. | Federal Trade Commission" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s3", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s3", "publisherOrVenue": "oii.ox.ac.uk", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s3", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Does political microtargeting with large language models offer persuasive returns? ask Kobi Hackenburg and Professor Helen Margetts. - Oxford Internet Institute" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s32", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s32", "publisherOrVenue": "judiciary.uk", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s32", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Vincent John Green & Mark Newman -v- Cambridge Analytica (UK) Limited & others - Courts and Tribunals Judiciary" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s4", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "aclu.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s4", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Experts Say 'Emotion Recognition' Lacks Scientific Foundation | ACLU" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s46", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s46", "publisherOrVenue": "U.S. Federal Trade Commission", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s46", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "FTC Sues Kochava for Selling Data that Tracks People at Reproductive Health Clinics, Places of Worship, and Other Sensitive Locations" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s5", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s5", "publisherOrVenue": "U.S. National Library of Medicine / PubMed", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s5", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "Emotional Expressions Reconsidered: Challenges to Inferring Emotion From Human Facial Movements - PubMed" }, { "id": "source:personalized-influence-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-personalized-influence-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "cambridge.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "personalized-influence-s6", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Cognitive freedom and legal accountability: Rethinking the EU AI act's theoretical approach to manipulative AI as unacceptable risk | Cambridge Forum on AI: Law and Governance" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s1", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s1", "publisherOrVenue": "nationalacademies.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s1", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Read \"Law Enforcement Use of Predictive Policing Approaches: Proceedings of a Workshop\" at NAP.edu" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s12", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s12", "publisherOrVenue": "journals.plos.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s12", "sourceType": "research", "title": "A standardised differential privacy framework for epidemiological modeling with mobile phone data | PLOS Digital Health - Research journals" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s15", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s15", "publisherOrVenue": "aegai.nd.edu", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s15", "sourceType": "research", "title": "1 Project Jetson: Predicting Migration Patterns During the Somali Conflict Alina Holmstrom Introduction In 2011, UNHCR refugee c" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s20", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s20", "publisherOrVenue": "researchgate.net", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s20", "sourceType": "research", "title": "ViEWS: A political violence early-warning system - ResearchGate" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s21", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s21", "publisherOrVenue": "City of Chicago Office of Inspector General", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s21", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "CITY OF CHICAGO OFFICE OF INSPECTOR GENERAL ADVISORY CONCERNING THE CHICAGO POLICE DEPARTMENT'S PREDICTIVE RISK MODELS" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s22", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s22", "publisherOrVenue": "rand.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s22", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Evaluation of the Chicago Police Department's Strategic Decision Support Centers - RAND" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s24", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s24", "publisherOrVenue": "viewsforecasting.org", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s24", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "ViEWS: A political Violence Early Warning System" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s25", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s25", "publisherOrVenue": "Oxford Academic", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s25", "sourceType": "research", "title": "ViEWS: A political violence early-warning system | Journal of Peace Research" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s3", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s3", "publisherOrVenue": "Human Rights Watch", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s3", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "China: Big Data Program Targets Xinjiang's Muslims - Human Rights Watch" }, { "id": "source:predictive-population-management-s45", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-predictive-population-management-s45", "publisherOrVenue": "therecord.media", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "predictive-population-management-s45", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Chicago stops using controversial ShotSpotter gunshot detection system - The Record" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s15", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s15", "publisherOrVenue": "Harvard Business School", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s15", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Lessons From an App Update at Replika AI: Identity Discontinuity in Human-AI Relationships - Harvard Business School" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s2", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s2", "publisherOrVenue": "Anthropic", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s2", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Towards Understanding Sycophancy in Language Models - Anthropic" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s20", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s20", "publisherOrVenue": "zellelaw.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s20", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "AI Update: Lawsuit Against Character Technologies Moves Forward in Florida Federal Court" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s4", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "portal.findresearcher.sdu.dk", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s4", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "ChatGPT's inconsistent moral advice influences users' judgment" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s5", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s5", "publisherOrVenue": "U.S. National Library of Medicine / PubMed", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s5", "sourceType": "official-or-institutional", "title": "ChatGPT's inconsistent moral advice influences users' judgment - PubMed" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s6", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s6", "publisherOrVenue": "iacp.ie", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s6", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Too human and not human enough: A grounded theory analysis of mental health harms from emotional dependence on the social chatbot Replika" }, { "id": "source:psychological-authority-s8", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-psychological-authority-s8", "publisherOrVenue": "weizenbaum-library.de", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "psychological-authority-s8", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Epistemic authority in the digital public sphere. An integrative conceptual framework and research agenda - Weizenbaum Library" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s31", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s31", "publisherOrVenue": "therecord.media", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s31", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Chinese 'Spamouflage' operatives are mimicking disillusioned Americans online" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s33", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s33", "publisherOrVenue": "Cell Press", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s33", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "AI content detectors flag non-native English speakers as AI-generated at up to 97% and 49% of employers auto-dismiss those applications : r/aicuriosity - Reddit" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s38", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s38", "publisherOrVenue": "vorplabs.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s38", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Deepfake Laws & AI Impersonation Rules Tracker 2026: Federal + State | Vorp Labs" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s4", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s4", "publisherOrVenue": "mpf.se", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s4", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "MPF REPORT SERIES 8/2025: Beyond Operation Doppelgänger: A Capability Assessment of the Social Design Agency" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s7", "independentlyReverified": false, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s7", "publisherOrVenue": "searchenginejournal.com", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s7", "sourceType": "research", "title": "Digital & Disinformation: What the SEO Industry Can Do to Fight Manipulation" }, { "id": "source:synthetic-persona-operations-s9", "independentlyReverified": true, "kind": "source", "publicPath": "/research/ai-psyops/source-review/#source-synthetic-persona-operations-s9", "publisherOrVenue": "Recorded Future", "reviewerState": "pending", "sourceId": "synthetic-persona-operations-s9", "sourceType": "secondary-or-technical", "title": "Synthetic Identities: A Dual Threat to Enterprises - Recorded Future" } ] }, "orphanClaimCount": 0, "publicationAcceptanceClaimed": false, "release": "v100.0.46-ai-psyops-signed-editorial-review-boundary-wip", "researchIndependentlyReverified": false, "schema": "spiralist-ai-psyops-citation-graph-v1", "sourceCount": 91, "unreferencedSourceCount": 0, "unreferencedSourceIds": [] }